I have been using this no poo rose mix since it was released. And I don't want anything else anymore. Nothing can top this as far as I'm concerned. My hair is fuller, my curl falls beautifully, it cleans very well, smells good. It took a while for my hair to adjust, but in the end I can easily go a week, and with the use of the 'dry shampoo', even two weeks without washing again. Although a weekly wash gives the most pleasant fresh feeling. My hair is less dry afterwards than with the original mix. With the hair oil it is perfect. Personally, I think nothing can compare to these products. Long time fan. And I remain so :)